Minastirith back to PS1 rotation?

by **jord** » Sat May 30, 2009 14:33

oh pls no, god of lags in minas. No!

by **Stillus** » Sat May 30, 2009 17:21

o no.. minastirith.. the MONSTER-LAG-MAP :/
--> vote no ^^

by **Plastic_Jesus** » Sat May 30, 2009 17:44

Why you hate minas? It isn't even laggy.

Its great map

believe me

by **MIKE** » Sat May 30, 2009 17:53

Saukko wrote: It isn't even laggy.

Not all people have in their houses combine harvester instead of pc Saukko

by **kerwinus** » Sun May 31, 2009 19:45

NO, horrible map

by **Vaakku** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 8:00

For numerous reasons I, too, vote for no. The map forces axis to blindly attack through open spaces often without offering any kind of alternative routes to the objectives. This does not motivate the attackers and usually results in a slaughter of those who are actually trying to advance. Best defensive locations are naturally narrow passages, which encourages the allies to massively bombard these locations. In addition the map is overly long but does not offer imaginative objectives but rather a gate after another. Lag is also visible but not unbearable.

As Bowdown noted, the polarisation of opinions with this map seems to be much more intense than with others. Because of this and the quite even poll, I would suggest that the map indeed would be re-adopted (as the current result implicates) but not seen on the server as often as other 'favourites'. This way those who like this map would be able to play it, but those who don't would not be depressed too often.

by **Stiinky** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 8:52

YES, i like lots of this map.

by **MIKE** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 10:08

Completly agree with that whak Vaakku typed. I would like to also vote for no cause mainly im really hard anti-fan of lags and thats my main point.
Imo I know that this poll will be finished with positive score, and I think that these propositions pushed here by Vaakku will be rly helpfull to reach consesnus between those who like this map and those who don't.

by **Es0** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 13:42

Well it is good for some players and it is bad too for other playaz....so i am in the middle of YES/NO...but PS#1 is mostly full so i say YES.

by **Ajdija** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 16:35

Es0 wrote:Well it is good for some players and it is bad too for other playaz....so i am in the middle of YES/NO...but PS#1 is mostly full so i say YES.

+1

by **__Mr-Unknown__** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 19:59

Simple question.... NO

It takes to long and I've played it to often. Some maps are just bad, this 1 comes after Fatamorgana, on my list of worst maps, if I had 1 . :twisted:

by **Evil** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 20:26

Minas back in i say YES ofcause

this map fit good for ps1 with massive ppl enough spaces (room) for 42+ people if u tell me,

ofcause ppl go whine about minas but hey its only 30-45 min,
and we got plenlty enough other ps server w/o minas in rotation

or just go spec do something usefull like get some to drink pee break or website look whatever

id vote for yes: cause ive request it few times in maprequest as i wrote above why i vote yes and want to get back in.

thnx.

by **Smadje** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 20:45

Evil wrote:and we got plenlty enough other ps server w/o minas in rotation

Its already in ps5, when people want this map they can go to ps5 imo, dont spoil 2 servers on it :wink:

by **MiLady** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 20:47

Smadje wrote:
Evil wrote:and we got plenlty enough other ps server w/o minas in rotation

Its already in ps5, when people want this map they can go to ps5 imo, dont spoil 2 servers on it

But PS#5 isn't so crowded like PS#1. Imo Minas should be in PS#1 rotation and delete from PS#5

by **Evil** » Mon Jun 01, 2009 23:42

LadyDeath wrote:
Smadje wrote:
Evil wrote:and we got plenlty enough other ps server w/o minas in rotation

Its already in ps5, when people want this map they can go to ps5 imo, dont spoil 2 servers on it

But PS#5 isn't so crowded like PS#1. Imo Minas should be in PS#1 rotation and delete from PS#5

+1

what i mean is that the map fit to ps1 cause its the most popular server of ps atm.
ofc i can join ps5 but as many players they stick on a server cause they feel placed arround well known regulars and admins

atleast i do.
anyways speaking about hudge maps like minas
offtopic: helmsdeep is big too.

anyways thats not where the post is going for,
but atleast iam 1 fan of minas

by **Viduus** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 9:24

Voted no ofcourse.

Running around in a giant mousetrap to be killed by mortar or arty for 45 minutes is not my idea of fun.

The map Oasis is to little for 20vs20 because there are only two entrances. In Minas there is only one entrance to the top for almost the whole map.

So if maps comes, then disable mortar and only one fieldops.

by **Smadje** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 9:39

To go further on viduus:

Also less Mobile Mg's, and maybe also less snipers

Maybe then we make it playable instead of 45 minutes camping

by **wuju** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 10:39

I voted No but if there will be less fieldops, less snipers and (omfg what i say) no mortar i can agree.. it can be quite playable.. but just time limited version.

I noticed sth interesting... look at score in %... there is 57% and 42%.. all votes is 100% so ... where is 1 missing%??

57+42 is 99 in my opinion

by **Xand3r** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:54

i vote yes cuz it's nice map to get hs and i don't get lag but the time is so terrible long

MVG<

Xander

by **kerwinus** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 15:58

Viduus wrote:Voted no ofcourse.

Running around in a giant mousetrap to be killed by mortar or arty for 45 minutes is not my idea of fun.

The map Oasis is to little for 20vs20 because there are only two entrances. In Minas there is only one entrance to the top for almost the whole map.

So if maps comes, then disable mortar and only one fieldops.

i agree with viduus,
but what is the use of only 1 fieldops when he is able to throw arty and support still that fast?
but okay i think minas will be on, some people like some people dont.
i wont pay minas, but thats no big deal we have 4more servers to play :wink:

by **Viduus** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 16:36

wuju84 wrote:I noticed sth interesting... look at score in %... there is 57% and 42%.. all votes is 100% so ... where is 1 missing%?? 57+42 is 99 in my opinion

33/57= 57,9%
24/57= 42,1%
Total = 100%
But I agree 57,9 should be rounded of to 58% :wink:

by **niknikik** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 21:31

+1 I miss it so much :wink:

by **MIKE** » Tue Jun 02, 2009 23:39

Wuju.. pls dont mention about %.. its mid of weekend so far!

by **MiLady** » Fri Jun 05, 2009 12:29

Imo voting started week ago and more people want minas in rotation. I think we can end voting.

by **Leo_The_God** » Fri Jun 05, 2009 14:39

vote NO

laggy map, much plrs use sniper, F-op and HW
Bad game

Minastirith back to PS1 rotation?

Minastirith on PS1 rotation?

Who is online