TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Our 54 man No Quarter house by Bowdown, Sebbel & *egglaf? IP: 178.63.72.111:27960
Server High Admin
Posts: 1601
Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2012 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Troyan » Tue Feb 04, 2014 2:13

Smadje wrote:There are tons of differences, and Kowi is exactly right. They are not comparable
- In oasis axis have a second spawn and they are way behind
- In oasis you pass an objective, and you intend to do the final objective, axis don't have time to reach the dynamites in time.
- ...



Yes i know that. I wrote it in posts above.
But im not talking about that maps are same or obj are same. Ofc are different.
Im talking about only this jump.
Oasis :
- you can go cave to do obj or faster way by blowing up wall. U can jump over wall but thats tj for obj. So u have to blow up that wall to go that direction. (or huntrick with covert ops :P )
Snatch:
-you have fiew ways to run, 1 is near axis spawn so... better not. You can blow up wall downstairs if u want go right side of the map (ofc there are two open doors almost same direction as this wall, but in this doors you r more exposed for attacks from terrace). You can also jump over the wall but this is same as in oasis ( on both maps u have to blow up walls to go some directions or jump over it ) --- thats the similar situation i was talking about. Not that maps are same XD

I see diferents that on 1 map you jumping from roof to roof on other jump from roof to ground etc... I see also that on Oasis, this tj brings greater consequences for defending team than on Snatch map...
But essence of jump is almost identical

Oke. Im not defending this map anymore :P To be honest i dont really like this Snatch map anyway :loller:

Cheers :beer:

Official Member
User avatar
Posts: 798
Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2008 0:00
Location: Cakovec,Croatia

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby DaRkMaN » Tue Feb 04, 2014 16:12

I just dont understand how will you alow this jumping over wall?
Allies call artillery on exit of axis spawn and it is alowed becuse axis have one more way to go out of spawn.
And Allies will jump over wall with obj?
How the heck will you defend obj like that?
And who will remeber all this, this is alowed and this is not things on different maps?
Old member will connect and ban people becuse he didnt read this post, comn.
It is not about do you personally have problem with it, but is that normal.

Rulebook
Don't use trickjumps or doublejumps to complete a map objective, for example; jumping over the wall as an engineer to blow up the fuel dump to complete the map. Doublejumping over walls or obstacles without doing map objectives is allowed.

"Doublejumping over walls or obstacles without doing map objectives is allowed."

And we have to discuss about it?

Official Member
User avatar
Posts: 690
Joined: Thu Nov 05, 2009 1:00
Location: nowhere and everywhere at the same time

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Sidor » Tue Feb 04, 2014 16:25

+1 darky :)
Better when we disable doublejump in all maps and problem solved on snatch and oasis too :)
_____________________________________
KaboOM!!! you are dead now :>

Talented Spammer
User avatar
Posts: 163
Joined: Fri Apr 28, 2006 0:00
Location: Finland

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Stick » Tue Feb 04, 2014 17:31

DaRkMaN wrote:Old member will connect and ban people becuse he didnt read this post, comn.
And we have to discuss about it?


All admins should be demoted so they cant ban unless they have seen this topic? ;)


Image

Server High Admin
Posts: 1601
Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2012 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Troyan » Tue Feb 04, 2014 19:13

And we have to discuss about it?


My reaction was same in first post XD
Its just too obvious...

And fact is that on 1 map this is allowed on another its not. Same thing, same situation, same jump.

Yesterday evening, some players also typing that some1 cheat becouse of this jump... Dont remember who was that but think Sidor remember :)

Imo, is it tj\dj for obj or it isnt is unquestionable. Ofc it is. Question is rather, do we have to require our rule in this case or not...

P.S There is also another map where is a lot of controversions about dj for obj. Falcon millenium. Differents in that case is that there is no wall to blow when u runing with obj. But when u run on right side and u have to jump on that wooden terrace, this is also dj for obj imo

Omg i was suppose not to defending this anymore XD

Official Member
User avatar
Posts: 798
Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2008 0:00
Location: Cakovec,Croatia

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby DaRkMaN » Tue Feb 04, 2014 20:23

Omg i was suppose not to defending this anymore XD


:D Troyan, we have forum becuse of this situations ;)
If you think you are still not shure abaout decision, talk.

Everybody is talking abaout their personal opinion, and thats ok, i have one too.
I mean, if we take Minas for example, i would use DJ with obj, climb to roof and walk.
But, Minas as Minas, whole map is preaty much DJ for obj, as long as we go door by door.

I dont have problem DJ with OBJ in general, i have problem that you say we can do it on this map and on others can't.
And i dont mean Oasis, there are other maps where you can DJ with OBJ.

If majority agrees, we can make rule that if nothing to blow or to build is in the path, DJ with OBJ is allowed.
Or something like that.

Server High Admin
Posts: 1601
Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2012 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Troyan » Tue Feb 04, 2014 20:39

DaRkMaN wrote:
If majority agrees, we can make rule that if nothing to blow or to build is in the path, DJ with OBJ is allowed.
Or something like that.



That would solved problem. Coz in rule there is nothing about blowable things.

If it is ok becouse there is no blowable thing, that means on Adler i can move with obj on roof ? Right ?

There are some maps where useing tj for\with obj makes for defenders crazy situations.

On Falcon: if u run away with obj through hole on right side of map, axis have to defend obj at allias spawn XD

Server Owner
User avatar
Posts: 2594
Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2008 1:00
Location: @motocycle

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby egglaf » Tue Feb 04, 2014 20:42

If you would like to discuss this further, then take it to the member forum. It belongs there more than here.

Spam Kid
User avatar
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2011 1:00

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Pingster » Tue Feb 04, 2014 22:12

DaRkMaN wrote: "Doublejumping over walls or obstacles without doing map objectives is allowed."

The problem with this part is that doing this can prevent other team from defending the obj. So, in a way, you ARE doing obj.

Example: dj to shoot the defending team while engy blows up an obj undisturbed. Forget the name of it, but the map with 2 walls that engy blows so allies can take the flag - people have gone unpunished when they doublejump up and shoot axis without taking the flag, making it more difficult for axis to defend the two walls from being blown.

Server High Admin
User avatar
Posts: 2194
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 0:00
Location: The Netherlands, PRIME-SQUADRON

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby davies » Wed Feb 05, 2014 0:35

Pingster wrote:
DaRkMaN wrote: "Doublejumping over walls or obstacles without doing map objectives is allowed."

The problem with this part is that doing this can prevent other team from defending the obj. So, in a way, you ARE doing obj.

Example: dj to shoot the defending team while engy blows up an obj undisturbed. Forget the name of it, but the map with 2 walls that engy blows so allies can take the flag - people have gone unpunished when they doublejump up and shoot axis without taking the flag, making it more difficult for axis to defend the two walls from being blown.


In an indirect way every double jump may support objective. To allow doublejump, we have to draw a line somewhere. ;)
ImageImage
ImageImage

Spam Kid
User avatar
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2011 1:00

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Pingster » Wed Feb 05, 2014 1:10

davies wrote:In an indirect way every double jump may support objective. To allow doublejump, we have to draw a line somewhere. ;)

Sure, but that line could easily be "if you cant get there without dj and without completing an objective first/without cvop's in enemy's pants" :P

Server High Admin
Posts: 1601
Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2012 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Troyan » Wed Feb 05, 2014 1:19

davies wrote: To allow doublejump, we have to draw a line somewhere. ;)


Sure. But imho doublejump should help player in movements (to make game a bit faster), not to avoid main assumptions of the map... especially when we are talking about completing objectives

Official Member
User avatar
Posts: 1174
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby DMG_Kowi » Wed Feb 05, 2014 1:33

Pingster wrote:Example: dj to shoot the defending team while engy blows up an obj undisturbed. Forget the name of it, but the map with 2 walls that engy blows so allies can take the flag - people have gone unpunished when they doublejump up and shoot axis without taking the flag, making it more difficult for axis to defend the two walls from being blown.

Special Delivery maybe? On Special Delivery, dj on those walls is not allowed.

Server High Admin
User avatar
Posts: 2194
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 0:00
Location: The Netherlands, PRIME-SQUADRON

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby davies » Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:06

Pingster wrote:
davies wrote:In an indirect way every double jump may support objective. To allow doublejump, we have to draw a line somewhere. ;)

Sure, but that line could easily be "if you cant get there without dj and without completing an objective first/without cvop's in enemy's pants" :P


That would be unrealistic. Doublejumping (and thus a little trickjumping) is part of NQ and, in my opinion, it makes gameplay less predictable and hence grands players more oppertunities to enjoy the map.
Also a defending team could use DJ/TJ to penetrate an attacking squad's plan to foster defensive play.
ImageImage
ImageImage

Server High Admin
Posts: 1601
Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2012 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Troyan » Wed Feb 05, 2014 16:04

But rules should be clear and works on every map in same way imo.

Or - No tj\dj for\with obj over blowable obj, but that mean on snatch this is tj, becouse you are jumping over wall which engi should blow up first. I mean that hole in the wall downstairs.

or...

No tj\dj for\with obj to complete primary obj on map (like on Oasis) , but that mean dj on Special delivery is ok becouse u only grabing flag, nothing more. Almost same situation we have on Italy. Jumping from roofs or from stairs to catch Cp should be forbiden. Only way to catch CP should be ladder...

or...

No matter blowable\noblowable. When you are completing obj (blowing up smth or catching and escorting smth ), you cant runing from\to obj area useing tj over high walls etc...

Im really think that rule should be one for all maps

:beer:

Official Member
User avatar
Posts: 2598
Joined: Wed Dec 26, 2007 1:00
Location: Estonia

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby deep » Wed Feb 05, 2014 16:51

The second floor wall is not part of the blowable wall downstairs. So tj for obj is technically impossible there. Only way to tj for obj in Snatch is at the bridge area.

makes sense.

I think the tj rule was created mainly to prevent chaos with skipped objectives and spawnpoints that mess up the map structure.

Server High Admin
User avatar
Posts: 2194
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 0:00
Location: The Netherlands, PRIME-SQUADRON

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby davies » Wed Feb 05, 2014 17:03

Troyan wrote:But rules should be clear and works on every map in same way imo.

I wish it could but that wouldn't benefit gameplay. Every map is different and you have to pay attention to it's history and purpose.
Most important
NQ maps are designed to use DJ
ETPro maps are designed to only use single-jump

Your exemplifications concern different kind of maps. Special Delivery i.e. is an origninal ETPro map, hence blowing the side walls should be considered as one of the main objectives for the attacking force. Considering axis first spawn distance towards the flag compared to allies distance, using TJ will screw up the map, because it would grand allies too much time for the final objective.

In other words: it would truly f*ck up a maps objective.
ImageImage
ImageImage

Server High Admin
Posts: 1601
Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2012 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Troyan » Wed Feb 05, 2014 17:08

Diamond wrote:The second floor wall is not part of the blowable wall downstairs. So tj for obj is technically impossible there.


But this is the same wall, only 1 meter below XD On oasis u dont jumping over wall, just 1 meter next to, on roof XD So is it really important 1 meter below or 1 meter on side ?? Imo important is sense this blowable things .... On most maps u can jump fiew meters farther then this blowable things. But sense is that you skip it...

Server High Admin
User avatar
Posts: 2672
Joined: Tue Feb 12, 2008 1:00
Location: Netherlands, Utrecht

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Smadje » Wed Feb 05, 2014 17:14

Troyan wrote:
Diamond wrote:The second floor wall is not part of the blowable wall downstairs. So tj for obj is technically impossible there.


But this is the same wall, only 1 meter below XD On oasis u dont jumping over wall, just 1 meter next to, on roof XD So is it really important 1 meter below or 1 meter on side ?? Imo important is sense this blowable things .... On most maps u can jump fiew meters farther then this blowable things. But sense is that you skip it...


In oasis there are no alternative ways to pass this wall (tunnel doesn't count, it is a different way). In snatch there are alternative ways, jumping over the wall is more of a shortcut made possible by doublejump. In oasis you skip an essential part of the map. It's a bad comparison and I don't know why you come up with it again.. :P
quoting deep:
henksmadje please read topic more carefully and other topics too where u reply, then u get the point and dont have to make stupid posts.

Server High Admin
Posts: 1601
Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2012 0:00
Location: Warsaw

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby Troyan » Wed Feb 05, 2014 17:22

davies wrote:Most important
NQ maps are designed to use DJ
ETPro maps are designed to only use single-jump


:) You are such a smart dude :beer:
That make sense, and this is best explanation till now :P
But still have mixed feelings about that... Maybe controversion will stay no matter witch way it will go...

:beer:

Official Member
User avatar
Posts: 798
Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2008 0:00
Location: Cakovec,Croatia

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby DaRkMaN » Wed Feb 05, 2014 19:16

nab Davy

DaRkMaN wrote:
"Doublejumping over walls or obstacles without doing map objectives is allowed."


Just to say this is RULEBOOK ;)

It all the same for me if we will allowed it or not. I am just saying that by allowing this it will only create new problems becuse there will be other maps and people will find new ways and then when you will kick them, he will call on this rule on this map.
It is much easier to say, no jumping over that wall with obj and thats it.
Davy you talk abaout gameplay and history :) i mean, it is not like NQ is from yesterday and now we have to watch that newbies whine about how they cant win map as allies, becuse there is very small number of them this days. Trying to "even" maps by bending rules is not the way. Some maps you win, some you lose. Learn to live with it ;)

Official Member
Posts: 549
Joined: Sun Jun 17, 2007 0:00

Re: TJ Over Wall With Objective - Snatch

Postby xochi » Wed Feb 05, 2014 19:32

I also follow darkman at this point. You can not put in Rulebook A and eventually do B. People will be confused by this way. Just pull ONE straight line and say Yes or No not a maybe here and maybe there, that only causes confusion for rest.

So for me still Not allowed.
Image

Previous

Return to PS #1: Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests