SC with mortar and artillery

[Betinho Profile]

SC with mortar and artillery in Bridges, for admin consideration.

http://rapidshare.com/files/173341554/2 ... dm_84.html

[icefrost]

in my opinion this is allowed. they could move out of there spawn and couldn't get hitted inside the spawn. i don't know the map bridges that well but isn't there a other way out of this tunnel? anyw it's like the mortar at goldrush (if 2 ways out at bridge).

[Betinho Profile]

i respect your opinion, but is the only way for defender the truck....for my, this is spawn camping, is impossible play with the mortar or artillery in this place (you cant pass), try to play with allies and you can see what i talking about.
And i m waiting for more opinions.

[Buuust Profile]

i think its not spanwkill bcoz mortar not land in spawn
and allied have other extits there


brainles allied got lots of darwin awards ! nice multikill

allied have very bad situations ,but this is war !!!!! no mercy

i dont understan allied?!?!? why to run in fire?! you can wait when mortar land and then go run fast over it before next mortar land and all be ok
it not sk

[Audio Profile]

I often wondered the difference between hanging about the exit and mortar. I do see some admins keeping an eye on things but again...if players hang about the doorways, they get !pip where as mortar is 'ok'

[Betinho Profile]

i think its not spanwkill bcoz mortar not land in spawn
and allied have other extits there


brainles allied got lots of darwin awards ! nice multikill

allied have very bad situations ,but this is war !!!!! no mercy

i dont understan allied?!?!? why to run in fire?! you can wait when mortar land and then go run fast over it before next mortar land and all be ok
it not sk

i dont agree with you man....i know , this is not sk, i never talk about sk (the mortar is so close to be sk anyway)....when you stay in 1 place with mg s, flam, panzer , artillery...and MORTAR and you need defender 1 thing (the truck) in this direction, in the exit to spawn, this is not fight, is not war, nothing!!!! you play bridges??? i dont think so....the truck is in the same direction where is the MORTAR. So, if this is not spawn camping, what is this??
I wait for more opinions (ps 1 regular players please)
CONCLUSION: this mortar (or artillery) in this map, in this place destroy the gameplay cause, and is impossible play ----> and must be not allowed.

[Smadje Profile]

Betinho ur right that it should not be allowed, the problem however is that it is not against the rules. think about that

when ur a smart player(like me) u wait for the mortar bullet and walk between 2 trough the exit.( not possible with smart mortars who time their bullet once in 18 seconds for the whole spawned group)

[RaiderPL Profile]

I don't like any campings players, special mortars killers not far from spawn. U have right Betinho can't be allowed!!!!

Greatz

[icefrost]

ye but the definition of spawncamping is wrong in this case. spawncamping usually means camping next to enemy spawn so he can't move even out of it or camping on own spawn what will provoce spawnkilling.

Deliberately hanging around (also known as Camping) Enemy spawn and/or your own spawn is NOT allowed and is considered Spawncamping (SC). SC will result in a warn (!warn, !slap, !burn, !fling, !throw, !gib) depending on the situation.

so imho in this case it was no kind of rulebreaking and even if its annoying u can also move out of your spawn without getting touched from the mortar.

when ur a smart player(like me) u wait for the mortar bullet and walk between 2 trough the exit.( not possible with smart mortars who time their bullet once in 18 seconds for the whole spawned group)

[Betinho Profile]

ye but the definition of spawncamping is wrong in this case. spawncamping usually means camping next to enemy spawn so he can't move even out of it or camping on own spawn what will provoce spawnkilling.

Deliberately hanging around (also known as Camping) Enemy spawn and/or your own spawn is NOT allowed and is considered Spawncamping (SC). SC will result in a warn (!warn, !slap, !burn, !fling, !throw, !gib) depending on the situation.

so imho in this case it was no kind of rulebreaking and even if its annoying u can also move out of your spawn without getting touched from the mortar.

when ur a smart player(like me) u wait for the mortar bullet and walk between 2 trough the exit.( not possible with smart mortars who time their bullet once in 18 seconds for the whole spawned group)

i repeat...i think this mortar in this map, in this place...destroy the game play cause...we play for funny and it is not funny....yo think is allowed? ok.....but is impossible play....1 only player is the "king" of fragger, just with put "1 click with the mouse" so close to the spawn, when allies need defend the truck in this direction, and you cant go for other way.

i m sorry, this is my point of view...must be not allowed.

[C3LIG4 Profile WebsiteICQ]

Well IMO its not SC & SK.

But yes, its a bit unfair.

But life is unfair - games are unfair.

But maybe there can be rule about that.

greetingz

[deep Profile]

if the problem occurs only in 1 map, then there cant be a rule just for 1 map. the solution might be to remove that map or make new- or modify certain rule. or just dont take what i said into consideration

[EvilDevil Profile]

Well IMO its not SC & SK.

But yes, its a bit unfair.

But life is unfair - games are unfair.

But maybe there can be rule about that.

greetingz

I agree.It's very simple.If spawn have at least 2 exits, it's can't be tractated as SK,SC,etc. it's unfair,but it's not rule breaking.